Hello, at the kind request here is the melody chosen by Gassy.
Let's do whatever we want with it, no limits on instrumentation, duration, form, etc.
Deadline August 18, 2014
Started by
Moderator
Moderator
Member
...but however...
Member
Romance theme ... immediate and simple ... that is where the difficulty lies.
Moderator
... more free and sparse than this
Member
You can do anything, it can also stay like this
Moderator
Of course Piccinesco, it is up to our sensibility to enhance it to the best of our ability. If I understood correctly, RStrauss is thinking of a Romanza, but who can say that it is the only solution?
Personally, I do not like the closing that returns to B-flat, but it is a matter of taste.
Member
For me it's always the same story, if I can I participate. I have an idea, but I don't know if I can know how feasible it is with this phrase.
Moderator
On the subject, I have at least 4 ideas; it will be impossible to realize them all and I will surely develop the fastest one
Member
Piccinesco wrote:You can do anything, it can also stay like this
or else maybe it can also become like this
Member
But that way you're taking away our little pleasure, what a shame.
Member
You'll see, Bianca, that now the usual Cristian will pop up saying that he doesn't feel free and that the limitations of his track will be due precisely to the fact that "he cannot" go wherever he wants.
Member
no but, excuse me, I hadn't understood that the theme was actually that, also because it's not quite the same. I simply thought it was a melody proposed by Gassy, which reminded me of the one I posted...
Member
meanwhile:
Frank wrote:Personally, I don't like the cadence that returns to B-flat, but it's a matter of taste.
Member
Thank you for the trust Bianca, I leaned on Frank, he proposed a bit of stuff to me (without knowing whose) and I chose what inspired me the most ...
Moderator
Bianca wrote:also:
It's not strange, consider that I have even modified a Rachmaninov bass. Everyone has their own tastes, I didn't write that it is wrong. Since subjectivity/objectivity was being discussed in other topics, just to clarify.
Not having much time, I haven't even accurately verified the link (I'll tell you why later)... given your doubt, I'll send it to you privately.
Member
Gassy wrote:Thank you for the trust Bianca, I leaned on Frank, he proposed a bit of stuff to me (without knowing whose it was) and I chose what inspired me the most ...
ย
I understand...
Moderator
As usual Bianca is right, guys... listen carefully. The topic has nothing to do with what was proposed, I publicly apologize to Bianca for not verifying directly right away. I was out and about with my phone and I didn't want the matter to blow up... especially since now I discover that even the topic had nothing to do with it. I am in debt to Bianca. I am very sorry for the misunderstanding.
Member
I am an idiot, sorry Bianca.
Member
mmmhm, I can't hear anything anymore. My goodness, how bad I am doing. Anyway, the melody seems very close to me.
Member
For me the problem does not exist, I haven't listened at all.