Antonio Soler - Sonatas

Have you already seen these being done 😉

http://imslp.org/wiki/Category:Soler,_Antonio

That's exactly where I got it from, but 34 isn't fingered; I'm going crazy studying it, I'm looking for a definitive fingering instead of just continuing to try things out...

Send the link or post the score, tell us which measures are doubtful and we'll see what comes up 😉

I really don't know it 🙁

http://petrucci.mus.auth.gr/imglnks/usimg/1/19/IMSLP49506-PMLP104239-Sonata_R.34_in_E.pdf

measures 52.53 the descent I don't know if I should do as I was advised and do right hand: always 4-2-1 left hand 3-4-1-3 2-4-2-42

or my demented fingering that allowed me to wedge the fingers of the right with those of the left 😴 5-2-1-2 3-1-3-1 4-3-2-3 4-2-1-2

I am very doubtful about it

Thanks for the help

I am moving the topic to fingerings and problems...

elenka wrote:

http://petrucci.mus....a_R.34_in_E.pdf

measures 52, 53 the descent I don't know if I should do as I was advised and play right hand: always 4-2-1 left hand 3-4-1-3 2-4-2-42

or my demented fingering that allowed me to interlock the fingers of the right with those of the left 😴 5-2-1-2 3-1-3-1 4-3-2-3 4-2-1-2

I am very doubtful about it

Thanks for the help

It doesn't convince me much, start fingering from 51... I'm missing something about your suggestions ;)

I would say... counting from where you start (51) to where you go (54)

51

dx 2421 3532

sx 1 51

52

dx 4212 3123

sx 3 2 1 3

53

dx 4213 4213

sx 2 1 24

54 you arrive with the 5

It's not bad Pablo, but I ask Elenka, what is your idea of phrasing in those measures?

My question is, is there a logic to it since it's a non-edition edition?

elenka wrote:

My question is, is there a logic to it since it's a non-edition?

Do you mean there is no reviewer?

Elenka, what happened to you?

Sorry! I've been working these days and I forgot to log on to the page... yes, regarding that sheet music I have, there is no editor; it was written with a PC. Looking online, I saw that paper versions exist but they cost a fortune, and for a single sonata, buying them seems absurd to me... anyway, I've resolved the fingering problems, now it's just a matter of perfecting the slightly more difficult passages, but otherwise everything is okay! Thank you for your advice

elenka wrote:

...anyway, I solved the fingering problems

Curiosity, which one did you use?