I am reading this listening guide
http://www.flaminioonline.it/Guide/Chopin/Chopin-Scherzoop54.html
"Scherzo in E minor" is often referred to. Is Carlo Cavalletti's guide clear to everyone?
Started by
Azzurro
Member
Member
I am reading this listening guide
http://www.flaminioonline.it/Guide/Chopin/Chopin-Scherzoop54.html
"Scherzo in E minor" is often referred to. Is Carlo Cavalletti's guide clear to everyone?
Administrator
Maybe I didn't understand the question. Personally, it seems very clear to me and I agree with what Cavalletti stated.
Member
But isn't the joke in E major?
Administrator
Ahhhhh... Hihihihi it is in E Major. He/she must have made a mistake, it can happen. I hadn't even noticed...
Member
The fact is that I hadn't understood if it implied a change of mode somewhere that, if I'm not mistaken, when it occurs aims for D# minor
Terenzio, try to check if it's just a transcription error or if it's actually a typo in the original guide
Moderator
Listening
Administrator
Fantastic !
Member
This topic had escaped my notice, so I am only making myself known now.
The exact key of the piece is E major.
E minor is clearly a typo in the original guide.
In these cases, I always have the doubt whether to correct it or if, to respect copyrights, it is right to leave things as they are.
Member
Terenzio wrote:I missed this topic, so I am only checking in now.
The exact key of the piece is E major.
E minor is clearly a typo in the original guide.
In these cases, I always have the doubt whether to correct it or if, to respect copyrights, it is right to leave things as they are.
Thanks Terenzio, sometimes an asterisk with a note saying what you have already written here is enough. Just an idea.
Ciao
Administrator
I agree with Azzurro, maybe put the notation (N.B.) where you explain the typo.