Book Review

Clementi's Sonatas

15 replies 3,218 views

Started by

G2013

Member

Member

Opening post by G2013

Posts
4
City
Bari

Good morning, could someone indicate to me the Clementi sonatas contained in the first and second volumes of the book: 18 Sonatas for piano by Clementi (divided into three volumes)?

Member

Reply 3 by Marta23

Posts
153
Frank wrote:

Which Edition?

Useful question, the Curci one for example.

Volume 1

Op 26 n.3

op 36 n. 1

op 25 n.2

op 47 n.2

op 39 n.2

op 34 n.1

Volume 2

Op 26 n.1

op 2 n.1

op 26 n.2

op 12 n.4

op 40 n.2

op 40 n.3

Moderator

Reply 4 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

It must be said that opus 26 no. 1 is also classified as opus 25 no. 4....just as opus 26 no. 2 is also classified as opus 25 no. 5.

G2013, which sonata were you looking for?

Member

Reply 5 by antares86

Posts
1,414
City
Bologna

without considering there is a sonata Op. 11 No. 1 and a Toccata Op. 11..... O.o the oddities of cataloging

Frank wrote:

It must be said that opus 26 no. 1 is also classified as opus 25 no. 4....just as opus 26 no. 2 is also classified as opus 25 no. 5.

G2013, which sonata were you looking for?

Member

Reply 6 by G2013

Posts
4
City
Bari
Frank wrote:

It must be said that Op. 26 No. 1 is also classified as Op. 25 No. 4....just as Op. 26 No. 2 is also classified as Op. 25 No. 5.

G2013, which sonata were you looking for?

My teacher told me to look for Clementi's Sonata No. 1 in D major, so I believe it is the sonata in D major contained in the first volume of the Curci edition

Member

Reply 9 by G2013

Posts
4
City
Bari

Even though, searching for the sonatas contained in the first volume of Curci, none are in D major

Member

Reply 10 by G2013

Posts
4
City
Bari

Thanks, but yesterday I spent an entire afternoon searching the internet to find out in which edition I can find it in a store, but apparently it doesn't exist

Moderator

Reply 11 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

Actually, like many others, I own them all, so I can check this evening... right now is inconvenient.

Send me your email address privately, so if it exists I will send it to you... from memory, one in D major should exist, you'll hear from me

Moderator

Reply 12 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

Oh yes, it's Op. 25 no. 6.

You can find it on IMSLP at this link (already indicated by TTW, among other things).

Moderator

Reply 14 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

Now I remember, I dealt with this a little while ago; Op. 25 is composed of 6 different sonatas.

Perfect and most celebrated is the fifth in F# minor, anguished and palpitating, entirely stretched in an expressive arc of pre-romantic beauty, such as to inspire, as is well known, a late-romantic writer such as Antonio Fogazzaro.

This is one of my favorites and it wouldn't be bad to at least listen to it.

For example, the fourth Sonata, less famous, is nonetheless extremely important for the pre-romantic character of an instrumental writing striving for a rich and flowery cantability, with an almost Chopin-esque flavor, which is something extremely impressive when one thinks of the publication date of the first edition (1790).

Thus, Op. 26 no. 3 would be Op. 25 no. 6 written in the same brilliant style as Op. 25 no. 2, typically Clementian (frankly, I like it even if I prefer sonatas written in minor keys... right RStrauss?).

There are also recordings on the market; I had obtained those by Pietro Spada... although in hindsight, there is better.

I am attaching the back cover of the CD

Attachment

Member

Reply 16 by antares86

Posts
1,414
City
Bologna

I'm a little late, I know, but do you remember she actually has a sonata in D major like no. 1.... (12 sonatas for piano vol I rev Cesi)

op 26 n 3
op 25 n 2
op 36 n 1
op 39 n 2
op 47 n 2
op 34 n 1

Log in to participate