I found an interesting documentary about Chopin on YouTube; the only off note, in my opinion, is Chopin's daguerreotype that speaks, eerie!!
Member
Opening post by giovannip
- Posts
- 553
Started by
giovannip
Member
Member
I found an interesting documentary about Chopin on YouTube; the only off note, in my opinion, is Chopin's daguerreotype that speaks, eerie!!
Member
The link?
Let's see, anyway to this day one of the worst representations of a composer concerns the film starring Al Bano in the role of Schubert: but can one (if the intent was not to abstract a person's thoughts from the course of the protagonist's life, thus interpreting the film by imagining two points of view, though I didn't get that impression) include melodic pieces typical of the 70s/80s while talking about a composer who lived about a century and a half earlier? Come on, it's not believable.
Member
Here it is! sorry I forgot to attach it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eKb7C7tN0EE
Administrator
I'll put it in the first post.
Administrator
I know this documentary. Indeed, the animated photo of Chopin is a bit impressive.
Member
Perfect, thank you.
Member
Yes, but overall the documentary isn't bad at all.... sure, when they have him speaking in the first person, I would have used portraits without animation
Moderator
It is honestly a bit "pathetic". It's already impossible, after only a short time, not to "rework" and "fabulize" the past. One must delve deeper and read. The book "Some Aspects of Chopin" by A. Cortot gives a good idea of who the composer was and what he had in mind. The fact of making his only photo speak is disgusting. Nothing else can ever represent an Artist better than his Work.
Member
In my opinion, this documentary should be watched by a non-“expert”; these effects entertain the listener while a figure speaks.. Anyone who is not truly passionate or finds themselves on that page out of pure curiosity will close the video at the first letter or monologue without animation/entertainment, I guarantee it.
Obviously, if you want to know Chopin, you have to read, listen, play.. but not everyone has taken the same path as some, so I don't criticize it; on the contrary, I applaud people like this.
Every time I open the YouTube page, I find idiocies that go beyond all limits; for once someone shares culture (done in their own way), I do not deny it, on the contrary