Harmony and counterpoint

"Enharmonic" examples

9 replies 3,487 views

Started by

Aspirante

Member

Member

Opening post by Aspirante

Posts
190
City
Isernia

Enharmony revealing itself as a nasty beast, harmonically speaking, what can we be referring to?

Moderator

Reply 2 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

I fear I haven't quite understood the question, but I would start by meditating on the dominant seventh and polyvalent chords such as the diminished seventh and the augmented triad

Member

Reply 5 by ScalaQuaranta

Posts
536
City
torino

recipe: "dominant seventh with chromatic resolution"

ingredients: any dominant seventh chord (e.g., a V7 of C major)

let's carefully observe the notes that compose this chord: G, B, D, F

the characteristic notes that determine the characteristic tension are essentially 2: B and F.

such tension is perceived more strongly if these two sounds are played simultaneously.

classical harmony tells us that B is called the LEADING TONE and has the tendency to resolve the dissonance by ascending a step;
F is called (in this case) SUB-LEADING TONE because it has the tendency to resolve the dissonance by descending a step.

so the dissonance (or dyad) F/B would resolve into the consonance (or dyad) E/C. right.....according to classical harmony.

but in a more general sense, a dissonance is considered resolved if it transforms into a consonance.

at this point, if this post were a flowchart, 3 alternatives would open up:

1) classical resolution: F descends to E and B ascends to C, on the respective harmonies G7, C+

2) enharmonic resolution: F (considered E#) ascends to F# and B descends to A#, on the respective harmonies G7, F#+

3) resolution/modulation: F and B, in addition to the G7 chord, also belong to the C#7 chord. by virtue of this, the resolution follows the principles of point 2), that is: C#7 resolving to F#+

4) resolution/substitution: the characteristic notes of the C#7 chord are the exact same (even if called differently) as those of the G7 chord. by virtue of this, the C#7 chord can substitute for the G7 chord, taking care to resolve the characteristic notes according to the principles of point 1), that is: C#7 resolving to C+

Member

Reply 6 by Aspirante

Posts
190
City
Isernia

Thanks ScalaQuaranta, as far as the dominant seventh is concerned, I think I've understood... does it also apply to other seventh chords? I was also curious about the other cases mentioned by Frank... I think he might be on vacation...

Member

Reply 8 by Zaccaria

Posts
105
City
Non disponibile
Aspirante wrote:

I was also curious about the other cases mentioned by Frank...

For diminished sevenths, what comes to mind is that D-F-A-Bb is probably in C (whether minor or major), enharmonically D-F-G#-Bb is probably in A minor

Member

Reply 9 by Zazza

Posts
250

For the augmented triad, think of "C E G#" and "Ab C E", the first is a I#5 of C major, the other enharmonically a I#5 of Ab

Log in to participate