Video

First competition

7 replies 1,812 views

Started by

pianothor

Member

Member

Opening post by pianothor

Posts
217
City
Mantova

Good evening, as some of you may know, a year ago I resumed my studies and since November I have been officially in conservatory... After a few months (7) I tried to do a "test" in a small competition, here is the video of my audition in Florence (2nd prize).. the program isn't exactly "competition" material since Beethoven is always a tough nut to crack, but I tried anyway.

Beethoven sonata op.13 1st movement (usually goes better)

Debussy etude pour le cinq doigts (usually goes better)

Rachmaninov etude-tableau op. 39 n. 6

Chopin etude op. 25 n. 12

how does it seem to you? pros/cons?

Member

Reply 2 by ttw

Posts
277

The technique seems good to me, a pity about the audio which does not allow me to make observations from a musical point of view.

Member

Reply 3 by nancy

Posts
521

congratulations on the result!! it's clear that you are studying a lot...! it's true that the audio doesn't allow one to capture many important nuances and perhaps the piano wasn't helping either. It seemed to me it had a somewhat harsh sound and didn't follow you in the pianissimo... I don't know, maybe I'm wrong!

take everything with a grain of salt... in Beethoven, the basses often cover the melody.... but anyway, well done!!!

Moderator

Reply 4 by pianoexpert

Posts
3,876
City
rocca di papa

it seems good to me.... even if I have some doubts about the dynamics at the beginning of Beethoven's Pathétique, but I'm going to go back and check it! Well done

Member

Reply 5 by giovannip

Posts
553

I like it too, well done. Listening to the recording with headphones makes it more appreciated

Administrator

Reply 6 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

Bravo Giacomo !!!!!!

Beethoven a bit uncertain but it's fine... You can feel that he must have matured and internalized it, but with the time you had to prepare, you worked a miracle.

Very, very good Rachmaninoff, perhaps a tiny bit faster in some passages where the level of tension should be increased (if one really wants to split hairs).

Chopin was also good, even if with a few small slips, perhaps due to emotion.

Excellent technique, the left hand was also very good. Hearing you like this, you should perhaps work a little more in the future on the differentiation of voices between the two hands, but considering it has only been 7 months since you started again, I would say the result was amazing!! My most sincere congratulations for the result achieved.

If you work a little more on these small things, I am sure that at the next competition, no one will take first place away from you!

Keep it up, you are a talented guy!

Member

Reply 7 by pianothor

Posts
217
City
Mantova

Thank you very much to everyone for the answers and constructive criticism; it is always good to know what others think of one's own performances so that the gaps that the performer does not always feel/see can be improved

Member

Reply 8 by antares86

Posts
1,414
City
Bologna

One thing that comes to mind now... on Beethoven, once the largo is finished, I hear almost only the broken octaves in the bass

Log in to participate