Four-part counterpoint — Pianoconcerto Forum

contrappunto91

Member

Posts: 14

January 4, 2016, 00:31

idk.... I think I don't understand anything anymore. help!

Tiger

Member

Posts: 447

January 4, 2016, 14:08

contrappunto91 wrote:
.... I think I don't understand anything anymore

Try to express in words the reasoning that leads you to say that Dubois' examples are not consistent. Is it possible that no one in over a century has ever noticed? I doubt it... so you are definitely confusing something.

I read that you are looking at page 97; the Dubois only works if you have done ALL the previous 96... did you get there progressively? Followed or alone?