Exchange of Opinions

Friendship between students and professors on Facebook: "survey"

4 replies 1,479 views

Started by

Frank

Moderator

Moderator

Opening post by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

I was interested in knowing what you think about friendship between students and professors on Facebook, obviously in a musical context, thinking of high schools, conservatories, and AFAM (Higher Education in Art, Music and Dance).

I am asking this because I read this article:

http://www.skuola.ne...i-facebook.html

It seems that in Germany one can no longer chat with one's professors. In the end, it seems destined to become a case of international resonance.

What justification would you give for this law?

http://www.skuola.ne...i-facebook.html

Member

Reply 2 by Zedef

Posts
315
City
.

In the Conservatory environment, it has never been a problem for me.

With some people, in addition to personal profiles, we have created information and outreach groups where we all post material that we find useful.

If someone uses Facebook in a non-exhibitionist way, I don't see what the problem is.

I do, however, know of friends, high school teachers, who do not accept friend requests from their own students.

Member

Reply 3 by Rotore

Posts
337
City
-

Just imagine if you tell your students that you haven't managed to grade the homework... and then maybe you are on Facebook from morning till night.

It is one thing to have the initiative mentioned by Zedef, where there is a popularizing group managed by a sort of entity not associated with a first and last name; it is another thing to read each other and have to filter what one writes in a personal space... with the doubt that your students might be there.

We shouldn't blame the German choice.

Member

Reply 4 by Lapushka

Posts
57
City
Roma

I had this thought a long time ago, outside of the "musical sphere"...

fortunately I left high school when Facebook was not even in its beginnings... but years later I too saw """friendships""" (and let's weigh those words carefully!) between professors and students.

I could go on and on with speeches, even going off-topic, but that is not the case; however, I feel I can say that one of the phrases used to "reprimand" the teachers is sacrosanct: "*there are alternatives for exchanging information and data*"

I do not blame the German choice either.

Moderator

Reply 5 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

Thank you for expressing the various points of view; I am not an expert on Facebook, but from what I have been able to see, everything depends a lot on how one uses their profile. If one's writings are aimed at sharing educational material, I am the first to recognize that it can be very useful, but otherwise, it can be counterproductive.

Therefore, since the law must apply to everyone, in my opinion, the measure taken is ultimately reasonable... although I wonder how one manages to control all of this, given that if I am not mistaken on Facebook, one can open as many profiles as they want and even "anonymous" ones.

Log in to participate