L. V. Beethoven

Gesamtausgabe

5 replies 1,782 views

Started by

OrlandiArmando

Member

Member

Opening post by OrlandiArmando

Posts
234
City
San Biagio di Valpolcevera (Genova)

Dear friends,

From many places, people refer to Petrucci's site (IMSLP) — to download Beethoven scores — which is http://imslp.org/wiki/Category:Beethoven,_Ludwig_van

To earn my rightful Crown of Thorns (but also because I have noticed many incomplete, erroneous, and missing files), I have decided to put the Alte Gesamtausgabe online myself. Complete. Without errors or tampering.

The Gesamtausgabe (GA) was published between 1862 - 1865, as well as being enriched with a supplement in 1888. (In reality, we are also including the second part of the supplement from 1890). The Gesamtausgabe is the first "complete" edition of the works of Ludwig van Beethoven. Its title reads: Ludwig van Beethovens Werke: vollständige kritisch durchgesehene überall berechtige Ausgabe. The edition contains 263 works divided into 24 "series," subdivided into one or more volumes (Banden), plus a supplement volume and one volume of critical apparatus for said volume (in this way, the works are brought to 309, which become 311 with the 1890 supplement).

It immediately became evident that these "series" were not adequate for the purpose, and at the fourth Congress of the International Music Society in 1911, musicologist Friederich Spiro proposed a general revision of the Gesamtausgabe. The musicologist also pointed out a series of inaccuracies and omissions, such as the four-hand piano version Opus 134 of the Grosse Fuge Opus 133.

Consequently, Willy Hess prepared a catalogue of all those works deemed authentic that were not included in the previous edition, which was published in 1957. Currently, a new edition of Beethoven's works is being published, Die Neue Beethoven-Gesamtausgabe (Ludwig van Beethoven, Werke. Gesamtausgabe, abbreviated NGA), of which you can find an overview on our site in the work details section.

There, now we no longer have the need to go to Petrucci (in reality, I have been to Paris a couple of times). The ultimate goal is to build an all-encompassing site; the path seems right to me.

Friendship,

http://imslp.org/wiki/Category:Beethoven,_Ludwig_van

Member

Reply 5 by OrlandiArmando

Posts
234
City
San Biagio di Valpolcevera (Genova)

The work is objectively excellent (let's not overpraise it, it is simply well thought out). The following part concerns the "dismantling" of the 311 works (though already partially carried out) and their subsequent individual placement. Now, if we consider that there are 142 Opus and 230 WoO (and without counting the 6x works like op.18 and 3x types 1, 2, 10, 30, etc.), at least about seventy are missing. As I was saying, they were published by Hess, and the big problem is that here the rights are still very much alive. Naturally, making my poor children starve, I have all the Supplemente zur GA in my house, which, damn them, cost an arm and a leg, even though they are printed on focaccia paper. The workaround would be to redo everything in Finale or Sibelius, which is feasible for many of them. The Biamonti give me less trouble, as they are normally very short and I can convert them from MIDI to Finale. In the meantime, I am supplementing the works with these PDFs, then we will see. Meanwhile, in a few days, the newly released Eroica Skizzenbuch will arrive, and so I will fill the gaps for several Biamonti.

A presto e grazie (aprirò un nuovo topic sull'eccezionale ritrovamento del lied per voce e pianoforte Hess 137 "Ich wiege dich").

Log in to participate