Free thoughts and words

I don't believe it...

7 replies 3,569 views

Started by

Thesimon

Administrator

Administrator

Opening post by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

Maria Joao Pires panics in the concert hall when the orchestra starts playing Mozart's Piano Concerto K. 466 while she had worked on a different piano concerto. I think this is absurd... Since when are piano and orchestra concertos not prepared together with the orchestra? Did they not even do one rehearsal? Did she arrive from the other side of the world 10 minutes before the concert, sit at the piano, and realize she had prepared the wrong concerto? In any case, playing the 466 is the same; even if she had already studied it, it's certainly not something to improvise on the spot without having reviewed it for an occasion like this...

here is the link:

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/damianthompson/100243153/pianist-maria-joao-pires-panics-as-she-realises-the-orchestra-has-started-the-wrong-concerto/

http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/damianthompson/100243153/pianist-maria-joao-pires-panics-as-she-realises-the-orchestra-has-started-the-wrong-concerto/

Member

Reply 2 by Piccinesco

Posts
1,231
City
Villanova di Guidonia

Can you believe that yesterday I was tagging you on Facebook regarding this very matter? Upon first listen, the piano part is not one of the simplest; at least, that is the impression I had at first glance.

Moderator

Reply 3 by sisifo1987

Posts
368
City
castellammare di stabia

Even if everything were true, after making a blunder like that, can one still play, even remembering a piece studied some time ago by heart?!

In any case, it would become a concert of the same nature as the blunder made.

What idea have you all formed??

Member

Reply 4 by Piccinesco

Posts
1,231
City
Villanova di Guidonia

And why should it have the same characteristics as the "prelude"; perhaps in terms of difficulty, he knew how to bring out the best. It is true that one cannot improvise, but if (let's assume that was the case) he had no trouble remembering it completely, it could be that he performed it without any hesitation.

Administrator

Reply 5 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

From other places I have read that it was an open rehearsal. In any case, the 466 is not at all a "concertino"; the three movements are one worse than the next, there is a very long and difficult cadenza, often Beethoven's; I have played it and can say it is one of the most difficult, certainly not something that can be played after a year of not touching it, so this whole business seems very strange to me as well, unless he had played it with an orchestra very recently...

Member

Reply 6 by Piccinesco

Posts
1,231
City
Villanova di Guidonia

Imagine if it were a publicity stunt, a staged event complete with extras to make the audience seem real.

Member

Reply 7 by irina85

Posts
58

I don't think it was a publicity stunt. I believe he played the concert not long before.

Log in to participate