Contexts

If you could choose....

17 replies 2,634 views

Started by

Max68

Member

Member

Opening post by Max68

Posts
9
City
Rescaldina

Steinway and sons - Essex UP123 o Schimmel 116 from '79 ?, we take for granted that both are in the same state of health obviously and that the Steinway is more recent...

At the same price, which one would you lean towards?.

Ciao Massimo

Member

Reply 4 by Max68

Posts
9
City
Rescaldina

I thank you for the answer, but I invite you to reflect for another 5 minutes; the Essex is an "economical" version of a Steinway, whereas the Schimmel is not, are you still of the same opinion?

Member

Reply 6 by nancy

Posts
521

I don't know the Essex and Boston [models] except by hearsay. I have tried several Schimmel pianos and among them there were many differences, so I wouldn't feel comfortable generalizing....

Administrator

Reply 7 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

Is there really a choice to be made? In my opinion, there are no questions... The answer is obvious and trivial if the conditions are good.

Member

Reply 10 by maquieto

Posts
665
City
Massa Carrara

To confirm what Simone is saying, images from the brochures they sent me. I am also attaching details from Boston, also of their production.

AttachmentAttachmentAttachment

Member

Reply 14 by maquieto

Posts
665
City
Massa Carrara

I tried the Steinway and I must say... the density and depth of the harmonics are truly incredible. Unfortunately, regarding the other models, I have seen many videos but I cannot say anything. Furthermore, every Steinway is a world unto itself; according to experts, one truly excellent one should emerge for every three pianos produced. Also, at the time of the trial, you don't try a finished piano, but they only have the piano body on trolleys, which will be finalized in a second phase once chosen. If I find the video I saw some time ago, I will post it.

Member

Reply 17 by antares86

Posts
1,414
City
Bologna

Yes, they don't make a similar instrument for you, but what you have done is refined, more or less like how we do with copied period instruments

Log in to participate