Hi, I'm 11 years old and my name is Primo.
Is it too early to study as a composer? I mean, writing my own pieces...
Started by
Primo
Member
Member
Hi, I'm 11 years old and my name is Primo.
Is it too early to study as a composer? I mean, writing my own pieces...
Member
Primo wrote:Hi, I'm 11 years old and my name is Primo.
Is it too early to study as a composer? I mean, writing my own pieces...
Why too early? I would say no: study and don't worry (but do study!).
Good luck!
Member
How beautiful, at that age they used to insist that I had to play the piano
Go ahead, demand to study composition (if that's what you want) and don't let yourself be fooled by subpar substitutes
Member
To me, the issue proposed by Primo does not seem trivial; are you sure that it is pedagogically appropriate to start this early? If I remember correctly, entry into the old composition courses was permitted up to age 15—sure, there is the word 'up to'... but it was an extension compared to, for example, instrumentalists who had to apply much sooner ("much" ... compared to a total of 15).
I have always wondered why... perhaps one is not effectively ready.
Member
Sorry Dante, Mozart composed in 4s.
An useful text on the matter
http://books.google.it/books/about/Children_Composing_4_14.html?id=zomJXuJ_vYwC&redir_esc=y
Member
Dante wrote:The issue proposed by Primo does not seem trivial to me; are you sure that, from a teaching perspective, it is appropriate to start this early?
I believe that our educational system, regarding music, is truly unreliable. All other disciplines are learned from a very young age; only music, for some unknown reason, requires more mature people... but who said that? Aren't essays written in elementary school? Of course they are. Logically: they won't be like university theses, but it is a first exercise in organizing thoughts and putting them in writing, following basic grammatical and logical rules. Why couldn't the same apply to composition?
Member
Primo wrote:Hi, I'm 11 years old and my name is Primo.
Is it too early to study as a composer? I mean, writing my own pieces...
I started when I was your age. Don't worry, I survived
Member
Fly free like a butterfly. Music is poetry
Member
Primo wrote:Hi, I'm 11 years old and my name is Primo.
Is it too early to study as a composer? I mean, writing my own pieces...
If you can start talking around one year of age and writing at 6... you can do the same with music. No limits
Member
Primo wrote:Hi, I'm 11 years old and my name is Primo.
Is it too early to study as a composer? I mean, writing my own pieces...
too early for what, has someone by any chance passed a law saying 'composition is forbidden to minors'?
How young or old you are makes no difference, there are people who compose from age 3 until they pass away, so don't worry