J. S. Bach

Johann Sebastian Bach, a graphic transposition

7 replies 1,856 views

Started by

Silbermann

Member

Member

Opening post by Silbermann

Posts
109
City
MI

Johann Sebastian Bach, a graphic transposition

http://www.ilcorrieremusicale.it/2015/10/25/johann-sebastian-bach-una-trasposizione-grafica/

I don't know, the realization of the prelude seems monotonous to me, that of the fugue doesn't render as well as it could. My impression

http://www.ilcorrieremusicale.it/2015/10/25/johann-sebastian-bach-una-trasposizione-grafica/

Member

Reply 2 by LucaCavaliere

Posts
860
City
Segrate

to me it seemed interesting and fun how the various "moments" of the prelude were rendered: in a polite way, without showy effects (as that prelude has always been, for that matter)

Member

Reply 3 by Terenzio

Posts
212
City
Roma

In my opinion, from a musical point of view, it deserves no comment; from a graphic point of view, it looks like one of those video games that my nephews are passionate about.

Administrator

Reply 4 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

From an interpretative point of view, I disagree with many choices.. From a graphic standpoint, I really appreciated in the fugue the fact that the voices were colored differently to highlight their entries. A beautiful idea, but I cannot imagine what follow-up it might have.

Member

Reply 5 by nancy

Posts
521

*Cute* but too elaborate compared to the artistic result obtained. ..it doesn't add much to the music!!

Member

Reply 7 by cromatismo

Posts
79

... just as Charles Gounod hasn't added anything either, for that matter. Bach is more than enough

Log in to participate