Leibowitz - Orchestration Exercises - Ex. No. 18

When is the deadline? Besides, at the end of the year there is the chamber music workshop... what are we doing?

well let's see if we can make it by the Epiphany, then at most one expects it.

uhuh I'm even early ....

Do you also have an mp3 of your version?

looking at the original I noticed some inaccuracies in the reduction. Anyone who wants to participate, look at this attachment:

ps

i could make the mp3 from Sibelius, but it is very approximate; I will see how it turns out and post it if necessary.

AleGozzo wrote:

i could make the mp3 from Sibelius, but it is very approximate,

But yes, a spartan thing

I don't think it's a good idea to reason based on the computer realization, anyway here it is

my version is the one with the correct orchestration. Anyone who wants to participate better shouldn't listen to the original, because there is a passage that is not very evident in the orchestra and which is heard immediately here.

Thanks Ale

so ? should I go with the solution or is there someone we are waiting for ?

eagle where are you? are you still digesting the big dinner ?

I returned yesterday and I have a bit of backlog, I'll see what I can do for tomorrow evening

I'm at work Ale, I just finished the first 2 lines ... the "easiest" ones

take your time

music blocks are bastards and even in the first 2 lines there is a little surprise (at least for me)

AleGozzo wrote:

note blocks are scum

Actually, I'm posting the part I did... either I move freely or I fail miserably

but do you want to take the time to finish it or are you throwing in the towel?

Carlos, if you are wandering around these parts: the Vln II are pizzicato .... do they really add color to the texture or do they get lost???

Go with the original

I'm not throwing in the towel, but I find exercises instructive when staying within the limits of ear reconstruction... if I go off on a whim, the objectives are different... and in this case, I prefer to work on my own pieces

AleGozzo wrote:

i don't think it's a good idea to reason based on the computer realization, anyway here it is

It's true, but I'm starting to feel the blow... these examples are getting tougher and tougher. Great method, thanks for carrying the initiative forward Ale

mah!! according to L., this was rather easy .... thank goodness

as you can see I have put in some useless duplicates.

.... or is there some problem with the upload or am I the one who made a mess

again .... (deleted)