actually I was referring to middle school students, not my instrument students
in the worst-case scenario (unsupportive course instructors, potential rigidity of the course, having to put oneself out there) it would trigger
a series of relational dynamics (at school) that are difficult to predict and manage.
I'll give a few examples:
- a music teacher and his middle school student find themselves being classmates in the conservatory. at school, the music teacher demands commitment and when questioning students he demands the maximum and is a bit stingy with grades. the student, at school, is essentially a 'blockhead' but in the conservatory, he is talented. a day comes when the music history professor at the conservatory intends to check progress and decides to give an oral exam, in the very sense feared by all students who are and have been: AN ORAL EXAM. that is a very intense period for the music teacher, between work, study, managing life, etc., and he is not ready to face an oral exam, with a grade and in front of all his classmates. can you imagine the devastating effect it could have if the poor music teacher were to declare "no, maestro, I am not prepared today" ??? in the presence of his student-classmate 'blockhead'???? beyond the real-time 'getting screwed over' (read: social networks), a sort of cooperation would be created among all the students, a loss of credibility and authority for the music teacher, a general legitimization of not studying and contesting the poor teacher's grades, since word has gotten out that even the teacher often doesn't study at the conservatory.... conservatory, the music school.... ohooo.... come on, our music teacher???? is he an ass at the conservatory????? then what does he expect from us?
and the students' parents? "how can... that little fool give my son a 4 because he got one answer wrong..... and he's the most ignorant one???? and then???? giving a 4 in music???? the most useless of subjects????? tomorrow I'm going to school with my son and I'm going to give this damn teacher a piece of my mind!!!"
not to mention the loss of respect from colleagues who, inevitably, would also become aware of the matter. not everyone, granted.... but gossipers and malicious people often hide even behind a university degree!
you understand well that the issue is a bit thorny. without a doubt, my high motivation would make me ignore all these 'nuisances'.
naturally, my academic qualifications and my personal studies on the subject protect me a little. but only up to a certain point!
thank you for your comments and I greet you with this funny video by Antonio Albanese:
which somehow summarizes or rather, implies many of my frustrations in this post!
anyway.... long live music, long live jazz... and happy holidays!
ScalaQuaranta