Apple Logic

Logic Pro 9 vs. Logic X

0 replies 2,011 views

Started by

Thesimon

Administrator

Administrator

Opening post by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

A few months ago, the new version of Logic was released... Logic Pro X.

The graphical interface is very attractive compared to the previous version. Here is a screen capture.

Some improvements have been implemented at the plugin level; among them, the new flex pitch tool stands out. Flex pitch is Apple's version of the melody software that everyone will know, i.e., the software that allows you to adjust the pitch of a singer or the pitch of an instrument such as a violin or trumpet in post-production. (In this regard, I anticipate that we will create a tutorial on how to use Melodyne).

Returning to the GUI, some characteristic parts have been moved; for example, the transport bar, which was positioned at the bottom in version 9, is now located at the top. Also within the editor window, channels have many more settings, including the ability to select automations and pitch types. It is also interesting that you can manage the plugin master from a graphical interface, so you can adjust the plugin's processing settings within the plugin itself but perform small tweaks via its graphic rendering, where the compressor even consists of just a single knob.

In terms of usability, Logic X certainly gains points, and it seems to be moving closer to users coming from its younger sibling "GarageBand". However, I find some things truly inconvenient for the professional user of Logic 9 who is transitioning to Logic X. First and foremost is the selection of tools in the editing window and the piano roll window. In Logic 9, it was possible to change tools with the key combination ESC + num?; in this case, I was unable to assign the same key combinations even in the Key Commands window because the ESC key in Logic X serves as a toggle for full-screen mode. This can represent a major loss for those who were used to working quickly using the previously mentioned key combination.

In essence, Logic X is an excellent system but, from my point of view, they wanted to change too much. Personally, I would have worked more on the substance, introducing improvements as has been done, but leaving an interface that wouldn't force the Logic user to re-study the system environment in its new facets. This radical change seems to me more of a commercial choice to sell this product to the much larger number of GarageBand users, who would suffer less from the detachment from the previous software in Logic X. In short, I, at least until it becomes necessary due to replacing plugins for version X, will continue to use the combination of Logic 9 with Melodyne editor.

See you soon!

Attachment
Log in to participate