Guide to buying a new/used piano

New upright piano... which one to choose?

4 replies 3,602 views

Started by

Elia99

Member

Member

Opening post by Elia99

Posts
3
City
Costa Volpino

Good evening and compliments on the forum.

I wanted to ask for an opinion regarding the purchase of an upright piano for study. I have been taking private lessons for about 4 years now, and since I am advanced in my studies, I had decided to change pianos in view of preparing to enter a conservatory. Currently, I play on an old upright that belonged to my mother when she was a teenager (131 cm in height and 34 in depth) G.L. Nagel Heilbronn, though I do not know its age (the only thing I discovered searching on the internet is that this brand stopped producing pianos back in the 20s. Consequently, it is certainly at least 90 years old...).

I love its sound—not too powerful, full and clear, with deep lows and limpid highs. The problem is that being so old, the action no longer works perfectly and there are other little problems: the dampers do not lift completely or at all when I press the pedal, the hammers are a bit worn (from this characteristic I assume that, despite its age, it hasn't been played much, excluding the possibility that it was refurbished without my knowledge) and the strings are a bit rusty. Another point to clarify is the tuning; since I have never had it done (the last time my parents had it done was 16 years ago), I don't know if, once tuned, the piano would hold it.

Given the situation, I have decided to buy a new piano but... I have no idea where to start! I haven't had the chance to go looking for one yet, so I am turning to you. The only piano I tried (still 2 years ago) was a Yamaha U3, but I remember not being entirely convinced by it, although right now I don't remember its sound perfectly.

Taking into account the fact that I live in an apartment building, I would need a "silent" piano (the U3 I saw actually had the Silent system) and, given the dimensions of my house, not a grand piano.

The budget is 10,000 euros, at most a little more.

If there were a piano with a sound similar to mine, that would be the best.

What do you recommend?

Member

Reply 2 by Boesendorfer

Posts
103
City
Tirol

It won't be easy - unfortunately - to find a piano with a sound similar to that of your... great-grandmother.

I would advise you to try different pianos, without letting yourself be swayed by the brand.

Even pianos from the same manufacturer have different individual characteristics.

Search and try; perhaps you will find the instrument that you like. Without rushing.

When in doubt, let yourself be advised by a trusted technician.

Best wishes.

Bösendorfer

Member

Reply 3 by Elia99

Posts
3
City
Costa Volpino

Thank you for the advice

Could you also give me some brand suggestions and relative prices for a model suitable for study? Just so I have an idea to start from

Member

Reply 4 by Boesendorfer

Posts
103
City
Tirol

The best-selling upright pianos equipped with a silent system are the Japanese Yamaha and Kawai.

Not only in Italy, but all over the world, e.g., also in Germany, where there are also large manufacturers of their own.

The Japanese have excellent mechanics and low prices, with a decent quality/price ratio.

NB we are talking about "upright pianos with silent system".

If you go to Milan, which is not far from where you live, go try them at Furcht (Kawai) or Griffa....look it up on Google.

The prices charged by Griffa, for example, regarding Yamaha silent pianos:

Model B3RSG2, 121 cm: EUR. 6,000

" P121SH " " " 7,800

" U1SG " " " 8,800

" U3SH " 131 " 10,800

Then there would be .....the Bösendorfers, or the Blüthners etc. around 15,000 Euro

Good night

Bösendorfer

Log in to participate