Percussion

"Out of tune" bells

5 replies 2,184 views

Started by

Historical author

Opening post by Historical author

It is always said: "out of tune like a bell" and perhaps I have understood "why" ...

I am at the seaside in a small village where every 15 minutes the bell tower rings

It's a pity that at certain times of the day, the two bells that mark the hours and quarter-hours seem to change pitch or even their harmonics; I don't know how it is possible, but the sound becomes truly horrible and OUT OF TUNE

Ideas?

Moderator

Reply 2 by thallo

Posts
1,170
City
Crema

the organology of bells is very complex... and I don't know it well enough to explain it in detail

but, in short, their shape amplifies harmonics immensely. Both in the sense that you hear a very rich spectrum, and in the sense that this spectrum lasts a very long time. If you listen closely, you will clearly hear at least the upper fifth, often the third, especially in village bells. But whether they are well-made bells or poorly-made bells, when the note dissolves you will always have a dissonant "aftertaste," due to all the other upper harmonics, from the seventh upwards, and this aftertaste will persist for a very long time, enough to create actual clusters between adjacent degrees. I have a church in front of my house; the bells ring jingles on 5 notes that are actually series of major third dyads, at least as I hear them. In the pauses, you hear all these prolonged harmonics merging and creating an unbearable maelstrom :-)

Member

Reply 3 by Carlos

Posts
759

And I wouldn't underestimate the "climate factor." Bells are made of metal, and if the temperature affects the organ pipes of a church, it certainly also affects the metal of the bells, which however cannot be tuned, so...

Member

Reply 4 by Zedef

Posts
315
City
.

I will add that, being formed by the fusion of a metal alloy, their structure is not homogeneous, so every small part behaves as if they were different metals (therefore with different resonance and harmonics, sometimes not even very harmonic).

Member

Reply 5 by Eagle

Posts
264

...apart. every quarter hour ?!

I think the scorching heat of these days is doing its part, between Scipione, Charon and Minos ... poor bells :?

Member

Reply 6 by Sergio

Posts
226
City
Priverno
Eagle wrote:

I think the scorching heat of these days is doing its part, between Scipione, Charon and Minos ... poor bells :?

It's certain that if they are especially dark in color, under the direct solar radiation of these days, they will reach temperatures exceeding 60 C.!

Log in to participate