Should the exams in question at the Conservatory be held with open doors or closed to the public?
Member
Opening post by Crazypiano
- Posts
- 73
Legislation
Started by
Crazypiano
Member
Member
Should the exams in question at the Conservatory be held with open doors or closed to the public?
Member
I have always seen closed
I don't think I have ever noticed "external" staff
Member
Perhaps these can help:
http://www.funzionepubblica.gov.it/media/263409/dpr9-5-1994.pdf
http://www.ilquotidianodellapa.it/_contents/news/2015/marzo/1427657929179.html#1427657929179.html?&_suid=143705049119709907991200150583
http://www.dirittoegiustizia.it/allegati/16/0000069252/Consiglio_di_Stato_sez_V_sentenza_n_1627_15_depositata_il_27_marzo.html#Consiglio_di_Stato_sez_V_sentenza_n_1627_15_depositata_il_27_marzo.html?&_suid=14370504859770887928358893354
6b.- [...]
This is an evident expression of art. 6, paragraph 4, of d.P.R. May 9, 1994 n. 487, according to which "oral evidence must take place in a courtroom open to the public, with a capacity suitable to ensure maximum participation", as well as arts. 7 paragraph 5 and 16 paragraph 2, of d.P.R. March 27, 2001 n. 220 according to which oral evidence must take place in a courtroom or hall open to the public.
Moderator
Oral exams are always and anyway public
Member
Selection exams for academic courses are not oral tests of a public competition for employment, but rather performance tests on the instrument for which access is requested. Therefore, D.P.R. 9 May 1994 n. 487 – “Regulation containing rules on access to employment in public administrations and the methods of conducting competitions, single competitions and other recruitments in public employment” has no validity in the case indicated in the subject matter, as it does not involve recruitment.
That being said, every Conservatory exam would be public except when it involves written tests (dictation for solfeggio, composition exercises, etc.) or oral tests that are the same for all candidates (singing for solfeggio, etc.).
Whether this is actually respected is another matter entirely.
Member
Thanks guys: magnificent!