Composition

Romance without words

6 replies 3,879 views

Started by

Zanzibar

Member

Member

Opening post by Zanzibar

Posts
26
City
Non lo dico

Hello everyone, I am opening this topic to find out how you behave when faced with a given 4-bar theme to be used as a theme for a romance without words.

Do you follow a formal scheme? In terms of chords, what do you use... are there rules to follow here too? Etc.

Thanks in advance

Member

Reply 2 by Dante

Posts
275

At a formal level, one usually starts with a tripartite ABA and then perhaps ABA'; in this scheme, practically the first 4 bars are the beginning of the A.

If you have 4 bars of A, you can then do 4 of response, 4 of recapitulation, and 4 of closing... likewise for B and then for A or A'

So each section is 4+4+4+4

Obviously, this is an example... at a harmonic level it depends on many things, not to mention whether it is a stylistic exercise or something more free.... so it depends.

I hope this helps you

Member

Reply 3 by Oracolo

Posts
317

for harmony you can for example use the scheme of an existing romance... see Mendelssohn.

Member

Reply 4 by Natan

Posts
239

It wouldn't hurt to consult texts such as:

Gorini Falco-Jorio, La romanza senza parole, Ricordi

Silvano Carella, Il componimento della terza prova del compimento inferiore di composizione, Bèrben

Member

Reply 5 by Valchiria

Posts
220
City
-

I do not quite agree with the systematic use of harmonic patterns, as suggested by Oracolo; I find it more useful to analyze and use the solutions learned.

Member

Reply 6 by Ludovica

Posts
298
Oracolo wrote:

for the harmony you can, for example, use the scheme of an existing romance... see Mendelssohn.

The important thing is that the harmonic progression of the romance you choose is not very far from that of the theme, otherwise it will be like apples and oranges... or you might have some "complications." Therefore, as Valkyrie says, analyze and then elaborate... using an existing scheme involves a process of selection that is not necessarily easy to do, or to do consciously, for someone who isn't properly seasoned.

Log in to participate