Piano technology

Sommelier

6 replies 1,073 views

Started by

RenziD

Member

Member

Opening post by RenziD

Posts
63
City
Imola

Hi, how were Bechstein soundboards made in 1935? Were they sandwich construction with cross-grained plywood or was it a single solid piece?

Can you tell me the pros and cons of enclosed vs open soundboards?

Thanks

Denis

Moderator

Reply 2 by pianoexpert

Posts
3,876
City
rocca di papa

Layered action beds. I would say the difference lies in the "construction philosophy." Bechstein has open action beds, other brands have covered action beds, others covered and holes with bushings. The pro and con lies in the seasoning of the woods and how the hole is treated during numerous tunings

Member

Reply 3 by sergio2

Posts
10
City
Milano
RenziD wrote:

On 07/12/2024 at 22:56, RenziD said:

Hi, how were the Bechstein soundboards made in 1935? Were they sandwich-style with cross-grained plywood or was it a single solid piece?

Can you tell me the pros and cons of braced vs. fenestrated soundboards?

Thanks

Denis

Quota

Laminated soundboards. I would say the difference lies in the "construction philosophy." Bechstein has open soundboards, other brands have covered soundboards, others covered with holes and bushings.
The pro and con lies in the seasoning of the wood and how the hole is treated during numerous tunings.

Do you think that open wind chests actually provide a significant acoustic advantage compared to closed ones, or is the difference less evident when playing?

Member

Reply 5 by RenziD

Posts
63
City
Imola

I personally had asked the question to know the difference between these two types:

closed sommelier

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/j2tuum95x033orsufty3b/IMG_20241207_115954.jpg?rlkey=1cmpbhfxg7zr717stxt5um3me&st=vrfw5c2v&dl=0

e windowed sommelier

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/5c2pc7qov40779tdhec7h/IMG_20241130_170708.jpg?rlkey=y6pvrvg16ehh7wnde1kkcu4hs&st=fma36kn6&dl=0

Denis

Moderator

Reply 6 by pianoexpert

Posts
3,876
City
rocca di papa

the link does not open. The Bechstein has a visible soundboard. other brands have the soundboard closed by the plate. But there is not much difference. They are design prerogatives

Member

Reply 7 by RenziD

Posts
63
City
Imola

Can you tell me what the "configuration" of modern pianos is called where the soundboard is at the bottom and above it there is the cast iron frame fixed to the underlying soundboard via screws?

Thank you

Log in to participate