Piano technology

Straight-String Piano

4 replies 2,747 views

Started by

lorbell

Member

Member

Opening post by lorbell

Posts
112
City
avellino

Hello to the whole forum and Happy Holidays!!

I would kindly like to know why straight-string upright pianos are always discouraged! What problem is encountered during tuning?

Does the same apply to straight-string grand pianos?

It would be interesting to understand the technical reason!

Thank you very much! ๐Ÿ˜ณ๐Ÿ˜‰

LORENZO

Moderator

Reply 2 by pianoexpert

Posts
3,876
City
rocca di papa

They don't hold the tuning. At the crossover, there is a compensation of the string tension. The entire structure reacts better.

Moderator

Reply 4 by pianoexpert

Posts
3,876
City
rocca di papa

It has been noted that straight-string pianos drop [in pitch] very easily. Crossing favors the uniform reaction of the frame and the bridges. Even in cross-string pianos, when tuning by raising it by about a semitone, the reaction of the structure causes the tuning level to drop again, especially on the high notes. So much so that one must aim above 440 to then stabilize. Evidently, in straight strings, the reaction and movement of the structure occurs in only one direction, that of the strings (parallel). Crossing favors a sort of compensation of forces acting in different directions. Good stability, obviously, also depends on the proper sizing of the strings. In the calculation, the Company takes into account finding a compromise between disharmony and tension. Greater uniformity and gradual progression of tension favor stability. However, larger sizing increases disharmony. The load on the soundboard is also important and, obviously, so is the stability of the pins. I hope I have been clear enough. In the grand piano, the phenomenon is a bit less evident.

Log in to participate