I realized that one of my areas for improvement could be strengthening the fourth and fifth fingers... which are a bit weak.
Are there possibilities, or is amputation and a subsequent transplant the only option?
Started by
Margherita1
Member
Member
I realized that one of my areas for improvement could be strengthening the fourth and fifth fingers... which are a bit weak.
Are there possibilities, or is amputation and a subsequent transplant the only option?
Member
Playing in octaves helps
There are ad hoc studies designed specifically for this purpose
Administrator
I am reporting the following Chopin studies that are very useful for the 4th and 5th fingers.
From Op. 10, numbers: 2 (Passages 3rd - 4th and 5th finger) - 9 (for the left hand, large stretch between 4th and 5th) - 10 (the sixths, the pinky must sing). There would also be some studies from Op. 25, such as the one on octaves, but for now I would say you have plenty of meat to throw on the fire. These are not simple studies... Aside from the fact that there is no such thing as a simple Chopin study.
Member
Ehm ehm...TheSimon.
Something simpler to get to Chopin (...maybe) with fewer problems?
Member
Chopin wrote:There are ad hoc studies designed specifically for that purpose
For example?
Member
I found it very beneficial, almost immediate, playing with wide finger stretches. To be clear, take a C-E-G arpeggio and use the 5-4-3 fingers with the left hand, and have fun with variants like C-E-C-E-G-E-G-E etc etc
Member
Margherita1 wrote:Something simpler to get to Chopin (...maybe) with fewer problems?
Above all, getting there alive
Member
Margherita1 wrote:Ehm ehm...TheSimon.
Something simpler to get to Chopin (...maybe) with fewer problems?
It depends on your current level of preparation. For example, Czerny's studies are very useful for developing the agility of all fingers (I prefer to speak of agility rather than "strengthening," which seems like a somewhat misleading word to me).
Take Czerny's op. 299 and then op. 740, and you will find many very useful studies. Of course, they are not artistic masterpieces, but they are often pleasant most of the time.
Member
Hello Maestro, with this last post you have given me a doubt: agreed on talking about agility, but for example my problem is, at the same speed, giving the fourth finger the same weight and the same incisiveness as the other fingers.
Member
In my opinion, one should say reinforce; jazz musicians don't like octaves DrJellysifh... maybe it would help them improve their technique a bit
Without taking anything away from you... eh! I have never heard you play ...
Member
uahuahuahuah! you rascal!
listen to Michel Camilo
Member
But it's true, doubling at the octave on the left hand is not very common in the jazz world
Member
in Pop it is the practice, in Jazz one only needs to think of Stride or Ragtime...
Moderator
DrJellyfish wrote:in Pop it is the practice, in Jazz one only needs to think of Stride or Ragtime...
... I can't wait to read Geppino's comment....
Member
you're not all that good either...
Member
... and then Geppino, in my opinion, doesn't think so differently...
Moderator
DrJellyfish wrote:... and then Geppino, in my opinion, doesn't think all that differently...
You know, I don't know... let's see if Mastro JazzPino makes himself heard
Moderator
DrJellyfish wrote:you're not all that good either...
... but no.... what are you saying ...
Member
The further I go in my studies, the more I realize how much strength, or whatever other name one wants to give it when speaking of finger movement, is truly superfluous and a pure chimera.
All "technical" exercises with their associated "studies" have the sole purpose of training the brain to perform the correct movement with the least effort possible.
The piano student believes they are strengthening their fingers by practicing and repeating the exercise multiple times, but when they succeed, it will only and exclusively mean that their brain has found the right solution, the most economical and correct one; therefore, the only forces coming into play are coordination, positional adjustment, and the involvement of the entire arm and torso.
In fact, every time a technical difficulty is overcome, one realizes how little effort is required to perform that movement, whether it is done with the third-fourth or fifth finger.
During the study phase, watching one's own hands while practicing is fundamental to playing correctly, because through careful observation, we can notice which and how many wrong movements we make during any given exercise.
Moderator
I quote Scaloppa's post!