Composition

The ideal chord voicing

23 replies 5,360 views

Started by

Frank

Moderator

Moderator

Reply 21 by thallo

Posts
1,170
City
Crema

perhaps there was a small misunderstanding: degree theory itself contains "a bit" of functional theory, because it does not speak of degrees as melodic entities (i.e., the scale degrees) but as bases for chords (that is, degrees of a hypothetical harmonized scale). In this case, do, re, and mi are not the first, second, and third degrees of a C major scale, but are elements of three possible chords. This "forces" one to take into consideration not only the bass but all the notes expressed at that moment (and to untangle this polyphonic complexity, one must necessarily use a theory of chords, which is absent from the figured bass ostinato). This also leads to the possibility that do, re, and mi do NOT even belong to the C major scale. It is not those notes that qualify the tonality, but the chord they belong to, the series of chords they belong to. This consideration actually leans in favor of functionalism, but compared to a theory where the bass "governs" and the other notes are found at random and senseless distances from it, at least degree theory tries to identify harmonic entities, i.e., chords.

I don't know if I explained myself clearly...

Member

Reply 22 by pianistamaggiorenneDi38

Posts
113

Frank, to tell the truth I don't grasp the concept of the comparison, as figured bass does not exclude the functionality of harmony or the progression of fundamental degrees, and is only a system of 'abbreviation' created for expert accompanists in the Baroque period, if I am not mistaken (I am not a history expert)

Moderator

Reply 23 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

Lidevosvuotare27, did you manage to download the document? The 3 theories that I cited and compared in the document (numbered bass theory, fundamental degree theory, and functional harmony theory) are 3 respectable different theories, as Thallo reminds us, complementary, but each born and used for a precise purpose.

Member

Reply 24 by pianistamaggiorenneDi38

Posts
113

no, to tell the truth I haven't seen the document, I will take a look

Log in to participate