Classical Music

This is what Beethoven meant by "Pathétique"

17 replies 3,399 views

Started by

Crazypiano

Member

Member

Reply 2 by antares86

Posts
1,414
City
Bologna

ahahahahahahahaha I know, I know all 3 time signatures even if you feel it, there is also the appassionata look

Administrator

Reply 3 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

This type of person doesn't make me laugh at all; on the contrary, it makes me incredibly angry... I don't know about you guys.

Member

Reply 4 by Boesendorfer

Posts
103
City
Tirol

My God!!!!!

It is truly obscene!

I feel so much pity for those poor souls who were listening to that pianist(?).

That wretch has uploaded more of his crimes to YouTube.

If you want to ruin your day, go ahead and listen.

I challenge anyone to play worse.... even while in the grip of a colossal drunken stupor..

Moderator

Reply 7 by pianoexpert

Posts
3,876
City
rocca di papa

I have also listened to some who teach internally in Conservatories,....who play like this. Cultural decline has always existed, but today the web disseminates more than the Mass Media of the past. Everyone can play online today. Once, "playing on the Radio" was a milestone. Recently I saw a short broadcast by Corrado Augias, whom I greatly admire, in which he invited the singer Morgan to help him revalue himself after the well-known incident of the "declared drugs". In that setting, he invited him to play the piano as if to say (or perhaps he said it outright..) "Listen to what this one can do..". He played Beethoven's Pathétique. In my opinion, it would have been better if he hadn't done it. And how it feels to hear someone sitting on television juries speaking with high-sounding phrases...: "Well, but this one.. is not stupid at all, thinks the listener"...and lo and behold!!!! Then they show us the lessons of the week, where, in their capacity as Teachers, they tell the "students" absolutely nothing that has to do with Singing or Dancing or Theater. Those talents are already sufficiently prepared to win and to suggest something to their Juror-Teachers. Cultural viruses are even stronger and the "vaccinated" become less and less credible. We truly need a real Renaissance.....Well, this time I let myself go....

Member

Reply 8 by RedScharlach

Posts
496
City
-

Not long ago, Ramin Bahrami was on Fabio Fazio's show to promote his recording of Bach's Inventions and Sinfonias. He played some pieces with the sheet music in front of him (which in itself is not a problem... but do you need sheet music to play a couple of Inventions that you have even recorded?).
The quality was depressing. Many intermediate piano students would have played better than him, both in terms of technique and interpretation (every cadence was a punch in the stomach). The piano was also out of tune. It seems to me like an additional mockery: "classical music" on television is never listened to, and when it is listened to, it is presented at an abysmal level of quality. At this point, it's better to say "no, thank you".

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thiKP6wN-k4

Moderator

Reply 11 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-

...why this?

MESSULAM plays Alla Turca: Mozart Sonata K. 331; 3rd. mov., Allegretto.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mr9Xfo8kOD8

...he managed to miss not a single note, even going as far as rewriting the finale from scratch.

Die-hard Mozart enthusiasts are strongly advised to refrain from watching.

Member

Reply 13 by LucaCavaliere

Posts
860
City
Segrate

these videos are watched with the same masochism with which one self-tortures by picking at a mosquito bite.

I agree with your comments.

I only add that, even if he played like Alfred Brendel, it would be shameful and unwatchable how he dominates the scene and how he enjoys the applause.

But setting aside his good faith (let's grant him that), the greater shame lies with the musical organization that supports him.

Member

Reply 17 by CromaDiBrera

Posts
558
City
Roma
Frank wrote:

...because of this?

They even put on a tailcoat... It barely comforts the fact that on YouTube, at least, he has the majority of thumbs down.

Member

Reply 18 by Piccinesco

Posts
1,231
City
Villanova di Guidonia

I'll try to "educate myself". Messulam isn't a new surname to me, Simò, you had already mentioned it to me a while ago when you showed me the video of Mozart's K331, absurd.

Log in to participate