I wrote this myself!

Dear niece

22 replies 3,394 views

Started by

Bianca

Member

Member

Opening post by Bianca

Posts
510
City
Torino

After some indecision, I tried to take up Frank's invitation and... not having a newspaper to mail it to, I put it here

“Dear niece,
since I could never occupy more than an underscore on the acrobatic line of your existence, much less would I want to waste the opportunity to make a mark that you can attach to your collections of names and interpret when the road appears most winding to you.
The world in which I live will perhaps appear to you as a past world, just as the one in which I grew up already seems past to me, and you may believe that the advice of those who lived in circumstances totally dissimilar to those you will find yourself in is of no use. And yours will be a conviction entirely consistent with that which each generation has always nurtured toward those that came before, until it itself becomes the previous generation. However, listen to me: your opinion right now is truly the correct one: you probably live in a different world, of which most of us can have only little awareness and for which we might be completely unsuitable. As you age, do not fall into the errors and the flatteries of memory, which sometimes turns into nostalgia, other times into pure fantasy. And do not fall into the opposite error either, thinking that your present is predestined to create a better future: too many times this hope has become a pretext. Make your present better, as much as you can.
You see, for the human race, current, past, and future reality is like a sumptuous banquet, opulent and vast and full of every delicacy, as well as bitter surprises, but it is laid only once. It does not restock and exhausts its riches as time passes. Those who arrived first were certainly luckier, not necessarily better, because they had a wider choice available to them. Little by little they consumed the tasty foods, those within reach, and little by little the followers were forced to explore distant borders to find something palatable still. Although the feast may appear inexhaustible, in the hope of finding new delights we must push ourselves ever more toward remote extremes and face increasing risks. For this reason, your endeavor will begin with a verse certainly more heroic than mine. However, the rhymes that follow, the story you will want to tell, and the outcome they will have—those will belong to you and you alone, and whether your inner future manifests as dark or serene will depend on your ability to face the present.
Deciphering reality proves to be a demanding task that requires special tools, and many will be those who try to sell you their package of solutions, some in good faith, others in bad. Take them all into consideration, knowing from the start that you will be unable to do without many of them regardless. Do not show yourself to be proud, because pride will not help you, but never give up on discovering the way for yourself, on building your own plow to cultivate your land and your hull to navigate your seas, on writing the songs to lull your children. It will not be easy and it will often make you feel probably alone.
You will dedicate a good part of your life to building the foundations and the pillars of your entire existence. This is the set of rules that from a certain point onward will characterize your game and distinguish your personality from others, the principles that, once consolidated, will be difficult if not impossible for you to transgress: in a word, your morality. You must understand that the fashion in which these columns are built varies, the material is different, the number and arrangement changeable, but unique is the way in which they take shape for any animal endowed with intellect, and such a way is habit. The moment when this set reaches a stable structure is the moment of maturity. The moment when this set ceases to evolve and is no longer able to adapt, that is the moment of old age. However it goes, this system will be indispensable for you to live in the world, and the aspect you have given it will be fundamental to the results you can achieve. Do not, however, mistake the function of habit for a passive attitude, as curiosity, initiative, and all your intelligence will be necessary to perform such an imposing work. You will face choices, you will make mistakes, and you will recalibrate your project until it guarantees you satisfactory answers. Be careful not to let habit become an obstacle; simply exploit it to your advantage, as you will be unable to do without it. It will serve you in every circumstance, from the most insignificant to the most complex, but always be vigilant so that it never compromises your judgment.
Here, precisely this, if I had to bet everything on something, is what I would bet on,”

on your capacity for judgment, which shall be responsible for guiding every action, every decision and your every thought. Learn to exercise it; dedicate to it more care than to any other faculty, always keep it in the foreground without ceasing to focus on it. Ensure that nothing and no one ever replaces it. This is the greatest risk, precisely because being the most difficult thing, it is also the one that people prefer to delegate, consciously or unconsciously. Those who want to sell easy myths, cheap progress, holy wars or self-proclaimed social policies aim at such a weakness. They will want to tell you what is beautiful and what is ugly, what is better and what is worse, whom to follow and whom to avoid. Always doubt the judgment of others, even when it is honest, because there is nothing more precious or any loss greater than this faculty. Cultivate doubt, a discreet and elegant companion, not as a destructive protest, but as the principle of a new search. Question your own goals and those of others and change perspective, but remember that these are not ends, but rather tools to reach further results.
It is only thanks to them that you can build an effective and solid morality, which in turn must serve to corroborate your judgment, like in a dynamic and continuous game. It is difficult to indicate a specific place or way to learn such an art; in fact, it is impossible. What is certain is that besides a natural predisposition, your teachers will be important, though unfortunately they will depend on you only to a minimal extent. You will only be able to judge if they are up to their task, and your purpose will be the yardstick with which you must evaluate them. Know that there is no notion they can teach you with such an objective that can replace the example they will provide. Because the capacity for judgment is not made of techniques and calculations, since it is precisely what is needed to choose where calculations and methods no longer reach, whether due to the limitedness of knowledge or the indeterminacy of things themselves, and because the capacity for judgment is what makes you human. Seek then knowledge as much as you can, whatever type it may be and according to your most genuine inclinations, and always find in it your humanity, which reveals itself in your judgment; without which nothing from that banquet will ever have any flavor.
I add nothing more, except to wish that one day, in a distant future, when you might have completely forgotten these few words, and when perhaps it will be your turn to face the arduous mandate of indicating to your grandchildren which horizons to follow, even then, that sign may remain with you, invisible and mute, never faded or extinguished, which alone will have guaranteed you human dignity.

Member

Reply 2 by danielescarpetti

Posts
1,032
City
Castel San Pietro Terme

Bianca, what you have written is very beautiful.

I have read and re-read it, and even now I continue to read, wondering if it makes sense to abandon such a personal and important piece of writing on any platform whatsoever - where, with difficulty, it will find a response. I hoped that someone would at least show some sign of interest in what you wrote .... but so far, in vain.

Of course, you are not Umberto Eco, and therefore your words, however important and profound they may be, do not have that power they would have if you were not "only" Bianca.

I wondered what you would have expected from this forum after spending a certain amount of your time writing and thinking.

I don't think the silence that followed - and thus nothingness - but some kind of reaction, positive, or so-so, or negative ... And however it might have been, it would have been better than nothing.

I would have liked to extract some passages from this piece of yours that particularly struck me and with which I am deeply in tune, but then I realize that I am in tune with everything and that everything you write is important.

The only thing I can tell you is that "the capacity for judgment" has never been humanity's strongest weapon. A humanity that, in its vast majority, judges based on its most petty and immediate self-interest, without asking too many questions that go beyond the tip of its nose; obviously, it is incapable of having "capacity for judgment." Nowadays, I would say, that capacity is even more obscured by a dense fog made of envy, fear, and resentment.

But.. I am a Beethovenian and I like to always end with optimism. Who knows? Perhaps your hypothetical granddaughter that you will have in the future will know how to reason much better than the generations that now populate this Earth of ours and will truly know how to use her "capacity for judgment" with wisdom!!

Member

Reply 4 by ttw

Posts
277

There was a philosopher who maintained that a people is distinguished by its prejudices. In the end, it's true, no one can be completely free of them and these are often THE CHARACTERISTIC of a people.

Member

Reply 5 by Silbermann

Posts
109
City
MI

A touch more than a letter, in the sense that it is very pregnant and perhaps too detached for an adolescent....but very beautiful. Well done!

Member

Reply 7 by Bianca

Posts
510
City
Torino
danielescarpetti wrote:

Bianca, what you wrote is very beautiful.

....

Thank you Daniele. Even if a thank you is not enough. You see, even if there were only a single voice responding, that would already be enough, or perhaps even everything we need. On the other hand, I believe that a single sincere response has an incomparable value compared to all the applause in this world, whether they be full or empty of judgment.

And thanks also to all those who have read, whether they shared it or not.

Moderator

Reply 8 by Frank

Posts
3,838
City
-
Bianca wrote:

I tried to take Frank's invitation and...

If only someone would "respond" to every one of my invitations like that... I would certainly be richer.

Member

Reply 9 by rstrauss

Posts
432
City
Udine

I'm back after a lifetime ... and I stumble upon this writing by Bianca ... what can I say ... compliments ... while I was reading it, a half-crooked smile of approval kept escaping me.

Member

Reply 10 by Bianca

Posts
510
City
Torino
rstrauss wrote:

I'm back after a lifetime ... and I stumble upon this writing by Bianca ... what can I say ... compliments ... while I was reading it, a half-crooked smile of approval kept escaping.

Welcome back! It had been a while since I wondered what had happened to you

Member

Reply 11 by maquieto

Posts
665
City
Massa Carrara

Morality that transcends into the structure and cornerstone of life. I would say... MOVING, I wish I had received a letter like this in my time.

THANK YOU.

Member

Reply 12 by Bianca

Posts
510
City
Torino
fabio73 wrote:

Morality that transcends into the structure and cornerstone of life. I would say... MOVING, I wish I had received a letter like this in my time.

THANK YOU.

Thank you for the appreciation...

Daniele, all things considered Frank was right again this time

Member

Reply 13 by Organista94

Posts
194

You're a bit demanding Bianca, I had to reread a bit to focus on everything

Member

Reply 14 by nancy

Posts
521
Organista94 wrote:

You're a bit demanding Bianca, I had to reread a bit to focus on everything

the good thing is, I thought I was the only one!

but trying to reach the right concentration (my deficiency during this period) I appreciated and shared it very much. thank you Bianca

Administrator

Reply 15 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

I only managed to find the time today to read this dense and meaningful treatise on life. I decided to wait because reading the first few lines a few days ago, I immediately understood that this post deserved time that I could dedicate to it. What can I say, Bianca? Sincere compliments!! If only half the people in the world took as a guide for existence even a tenth of the words you have written, our world would probably be a better place.

In the melancholy of your letter, given from the perspective of someone who has long observed the steps taken and has tried to imagine those yet to be made, I was impressed by the naturalness in the choice of such bold and refined terms that seem to flow with great ease from the soul.

However, I perceived an underlying optimism that accompanies the entire reading, a "if you know how to choose, then you will see that...".

Unfortunately, in some cases, we are unable to be masters of our choices. Events fall upon us and we must try to accept them for what they are, perhaps grasping their positive aspects, namely the idea that all in all we are ephemeral beings; for some, life presents itself as a beautiful oasis similar to paradise, others are forced to live as if they were flies in the ocean at the mercy of the waves, and it is precisely for these latter people that it is difficult to spend their existence reflecting on the choices to be made or trying to grasp the lessons of past choices: whether right or wrong. I think of those who grew up in the streets and did not have the luck of having parents or aunts/uncles like you, who tried to provide guidelines for existence. I think of those who die of hunger, where the concern is not finding errors and grasping their positive nuances with the opportunity to grow, but rather obtaining food while living in the hell of not knowing if they will continue to open their eyes tomorrow to obtain more. I think of those who, struck by serious illnesses, wonder why destiny has reserved this end for them. I think that for many life is unfair because everyone should have the opportunity to engage with your words, to make choices, to build their own lives, to choose how to live their existence, and it is here that the key concept, in my opinion, shifts to time, which we can interpret as either our executioner or our ally. We are slaves to a dimension that inexorably escapes us, and probably if we could control it or if it did not exist, our choices would be much less careful. The necessity of reckoning with time puts us in a position to think carefully about our choices because, as you recall in your letter, choices will decide the direction of our lives. Our choices influence the time of our lives and the quality of the time we live. But your letter gives me a strong dose of hope because despite us, beings so small in the face of creation representing nothing, we are nonetheless able to forge from our minds such high thoughts with the spirit of improving our existence and that of future generations to leave something of ourselves to posterity, to our children, to our grandchildren, just as you have done in your letter by attempting, if nothing else, to continue living even after death in the thoughts, in the heart, and in the lives of other people who will have read, shared, and made your thoughts their own. Congratulations once again.

Member

Reply 16 by Bianca

Posts
510
City
Torino
TheSimon wrote:

I only managed to find the time to read today

Thank you Simone for your beautiful words, which perhaps I don't even deserve...

And thanks again to everyone else for sharing.

Administrator

Reply 17 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

Those who know me know that I am notoriously stingy with compliments... Or perhaps it is me who finds it difficult to express the beauty of what you have written.

Administrator

Reply 19 by Thesimon

Posts
4,504
City
Ariccia, RM

But look, in my opinion, nothing has changed. I believe Umberto Eco was mistaken in this context.

Before there were books to provide information, today there is the internet; the method of absorption and the speed with which information can be retrieved have changed, but I don't see such a disruption as to call into question the existence of a professor.

Once, I could take a book and study independently; today, I can open the internet and study independently. I don't understand the implications of this upheaval... The professor is there to simplify your work, to fill in your doubts; they are a well to draw from when we need it, in print as well as in the digital era. Studying mathematics on a website or in a book is the same thing and requires time, a lot of time; studying it with a professor is much faster and more intuitive: they can give you examples, perform exercises, go through more steps to make you understand and instill a method.

Personally, when I had to study alone from books, it took me longer to absorb the concepts and anyway always in a very volatile way. I don't remember the details of what I studied on my own very well, and I often have to pick up the book again to read some constructions.

I remember very well everything I studied by listening to the lecture and taking notes, to the point that, especially in university, I almost never opened a book. I would restudy my notes and use the book only to integrate some information that might have only been mentioned by the professor.

Therefore, even setting aside all the merits of the professor's training of the student, speaking specifically about the teacher-student transmission of information, I honestly cannot see this tremendous change to the point of saying: "What is the use of a professor?". To do what they did before, and perhaps in a better way since today it is possible to retrieve information in the blink of an eye.

Member

Reply 20 by Bianca

Posts
510
City
Torino

Julius Caesar, in the sixth book of the Gallic War, describes the Druids and their custom of forbidding the codification of their doctrine through writing. Since he speaks of a twenty-year initiation, we can imagine that this required a considerable learning effort. This custom, Caesar says, had a dual purpose: to avoid the disclosure of their doctrine and their formulas and to prevent the weakening of the mind ("...it happens to everyone, in fact, that being able to avail oneself of writing, one applies oneself less to study...")
I have a colleague, who is certainly not Julius Caesar, but who has always refused to use a calculator to perform most calculations, as almost all of us do. The reason is simple: he says he prefers to keep his brain trained.
Now, the fact that almost all information is available in real time is a very complex and far-reaching problem, which perhaps cannot be dismissed in a few lines.
Still, try a simple test: how many times has it happened to you that you had to search for something you had already searched for? And the reason is not just because you no longer remember it, but perhaps because you no longer even remember the way you understood it: "it does not make science, without retaining it, to have understood"
School has always had to educate more than inform, and this is well known, but too often it fails and has failed in this purpose. Paradoxically today (and in this regard, as much as Simone says, which I share), where the risk seems greatest, teachers themselves have a greater opportunity compared to the past to demonstrate that they are able to fulfill this function. And here, obviously, returns the importance of knowing how to develop and cultivate memory and judgment.
It is also clear that one must distinguish between information and comprehension; anyone can find and read Cauchy's theorem, but not for this reason do they understand it, and it is the teacher's task to explain its meaning and use. Although it is true that on the web one can find who or what replaces a teacher, and parts of this forum are an example of this.
Here then we arrive at a point that does not seem to have been touched upon in the article: the social importance of school and teachers. Social, not "social" [as in social media]. I believe, in fact, that even if all other aspects of training and education could be transformed and swallowed up by a phenomenon like the web, the importance of the social and human relationship that school and the real teacher introduce remains, by definition, insurmountable.

Log in to participate